I think that this semester really improved my ability to
write. Being an engineering student I don’t have to take many English classes
but I feel that I got a lot out of 1206. In the past to write a paper all I would
have to do is write down facts I already knew and had a specific path the
follow. This class was different. Starting with the Shelby Lee Adams paper we
had to choose a side and then argue for it and against the other side. It made
me think about both sides of the argument as I wrote. Next the Inquiry was my
favorite paper. This time we got to choose the topic. The idea of answering a
question in an essay was new to me but I really enjoyed writing the paper. I
had always thought about my inquiry question but this time I had the chance to
write a paper about and express my opinions. The last paper was the science feature
and again since we were able to choose the topic I enjoyed this paper a lot too.
I learned a lot about my topic the higgs boson and what I learned will help me
in future classes as well. All of these paper were effective in teaching me a
new way to write. They were so much different than paper I have done in high
school and I learned a lot which will help me to be a better writer in the
future.
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Joslin's review of Freed
Peer Review and
Commentary—Science Feature AJ Joslin review of Bret Freed
The Lead:
How
does the lead pull the reader in and entice her to read on? Is it surprising, or are claims made that are
common knowledge (note: the reader shouldn’t be able to say, ‘well duh.’)? Is it effective? Can it be made more effective? (think details, human drama, evocative
language—why do/don’t you want to read on?)
The author has a strong lead. They make the reader think of a world where
everything is theirs and they can do whatever they want. Seems impossible but
it is a lucid dream.
Does
the lead give a clear indication of what the story will be about, or rely on
mystery, or both? Would more of a focus
be helpful? Is the reader aware of the
importance of a topic—why it matters and is worth learning about? Adversely, if for more entertainment
purposes, is the topic engaging enough to compel reading?
The author give us the topic of the paper in the title and towards
the end of the first paragraph. They don’t rely on mystery.
Organization:
Consider
how the story is structured.
Chronological, thematic, chapter/section-based, inquiry-driven? Is it effective? Be specific—if a paragraph doesn’t transition
well into the next, mention it and provide suggestions for improvement.
The paper is organized. It starts off with the intro, then the
science behind dreaming, lucid dreaming, and then experiments related to lucid
dreaming.
Is
each paragraph well focused, or are several ideas competing for attention? How can better focus be achieved?
The paragraph about the author’s experiments and scientist experiments
seem to overlap towards the end. Besides that they are strong.
Are
there certain points (factual or narrative based) that require more
development? Are you, the reader,
unclear at certain points? Are any ideas
superfluous or distracting?
I think the ending needs more development. We get the science behind
dreaming and then experiments but then it just ends.
Balance
of human interest and information. Point
out sections that become too bogged down in dry facts or heavily specialized
concepts. Adversely, find sections that
rely on narrative without giving the reader proper background information and
factual points of reference.
I think the balance works in the paper.
Are
claims backed up by examples, evidence, research? Are sensory details employed
effectively? Are abstractions made
concrete through use of examples and details?
Claims are backed up by people’s recorded experiences
How
is the story concluded? Does it wrap up
the topic neatly and provide closure?
Does it ask bigger questions or compel the reader to search for more? Are you left wanting more (and is this a good
thing)? Is it effective?
The conclusion comes up fast. The author talks about the idea of a
dream mirror and then the paper ends. I think a few paragraphs could be added
to the end. Maybe one more new idea and then a complete conclusion.
Voice and
Audience
Characterize
the story’s voice and tone? Is it
suitable for the topic? Is it
engaging? Is it consistent throughout
the piece? If first person POV is used,
is this effective or jarring (remember, most story’s should rely on the
strength of the topic for engagement, not the evidence of authorial intrusion).
The author tone works for this paper. They are very curious in the
topic and making lucid dreaming work. Not all he answer are known on this topic
so the paper doesn’t have all the answer either. The voice is effective for
what the author is talking about.
Try
to characterize the audience. What venue
(publication) do you think this story suits?
Why? Does the author effectively
address this audience (too dumbed-down or sensational, too dry and esoteric)?
This could apply to anyone. Since everyone dreams, any person could
be interested in lucid dreaming. With the science background this paper could
be read by almost anyone.
Mechanics
Mark
any ineffective or over-used word/phrase choices. Mark any repetitive sentence structures. Offer advice on vocabulary, syntax, and
sentence structure.
Mark
other grammar issues and typos.
Marked on paper
Thursday, April 10, 2014
Outline
To start off my paper I am going to write about the Large
Hadron Collider in Geneva Switzerland. The Large Hadron Collider was built in
collaboration with over 10,000 scientists and engineers from over 100
countries, as well as hundreds of universities and laboratories. It lies in a
tunnel 27 kilometers (17 mi) in circumference, as deep as 175 meters (574 ft.)
beneath the ground. It accelerates particles at nearly the speed of light
around the 27 kilometer circle and Atlas is a super computer that can read the
data of the particle collision.
I plan to then go to into a bit of history and write about
Peter Higgs and his ideas.
After that I will explain the higgs boson also known as the
“god particle”, is the particle that gives matter mass. The higgs boson
interacts with the Higgs field and this gives particles mass. The larger the
particle the more it interacts with the field and the more mass it has.
I will then relate the Large Hadron Collider to the higgs
boson and explain how Albert Einstein’s famous equation of E=mc2
ties them together.
Before I conclude the paper I will talk about the impact of
finding the higgs boson on modern physics and what it means moving forward in
science. Since finding it 2012 revolutionized physicist ideas of the origin of
mass.
This is a big topic to write about. I hope the Large Hadron
Collider and the facts behind it will keep the reader interested as I explain
the history, the higgs boson and the impact of its discovery.
Tuesday, April 8, 2014
Questions
The biggest question I will have to answer is what is the
higgs boson? In the most simple explanation higgs boson, also known as the “god
particle”, is the particle that gives matter mass. Finding it 2012
revolutionized physicist ideas of the origin of mass. The higgs boson interacts
with the Higgs field and this gives particles mass. The larger the particle the
more it interacts with the field and the more mass it has. How is a particle
detected? Using the Atlas detector of the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva Switzerland.
The LHC was built in collaboration with over 10,000 scientists and engineers
from over 100 countries, as well as hundreds of universities and laboratories. It
lies in a tunnel 27 kilometers (17 mi) in circumference, as deep as 175 meters
(574 ft.) beneath the ground. It accelerates particles at nearly the speed of
light around the 27 kilometer circle and Atlas is a super computer that can
read the data of the particle collision. How does colliding particles get this
particle? Einstein’s famous equation E=mc2 tell us that mass is just
another form of energy. By speeding the particles up to nearly the speed of
light, the collision turns this energy into many particles and it is just a
matter of Atlas capturing this data. The question of why is it named higgs? The
particle is named after Dr. Peter Higgs after he predicted such a particle
should exist in 1964. He thought an energy field permeated the entire universe,
later called the higgs field.
Sunday, April 6, 2014
Student Essays
I choose to look at Student Essay’s 4 and 8. Titled “Per
Aspera Ad Astra” and “Watson’s Big Day”. Both start off with a single sentence before
their body paragraphs. Essay 4 starts off with a sentence that reads “Seventeen
seconds. Seventeen goddamn seconds was
all it took to lose those three men.” Not knowing what the title meant this statement
grabs anyone attention. Essay 8 “Good afternoon, Mr. Trebek, I have been
waiting for a very, very, very long time.” Neither statements reference what exactly
is the topic of the articles but they get your attention or curiosity. This is
what I will need when I write about the Higgs Boson. It is a big topic and can
be very difficult to explain so I want a strong introduction so I don’t lose my
readers right off the start. Both of these article have the one sentence
introduction that does a strong job. After further reading we see that Essay 8
is about Watson the computer and its ability to communicate with humans and the
article lead into Artificial Intelligence. Essay 4 is about the death of three
men abroad a practice test. A fire broke out and burned the three men. This
article has an interesting twist. They start with the opening statement but then
go through to history and lead to their initial statement. Along the way there
are short statements that are related to the fire and death of the men. The author
keeps you reading since you get taste of what is to come after going through
the history. I now have more ideas on how I will tackle the paper of writing about
the Higgs Boson.
Bring them back to Life
“Bring them back to Life” does an excellent job of keeping
my attention in the introduction. They article talks about bringing an extinct
creature back to life. Right away this made me think of the scene from Jurassic
Park when the blood is being drawn the mosquito in the amber and how they had
breed dinosaurs back in existence. This idea of de-extinction seemed just like an
idea from science fiction. I thought it was interesting that after reading the
intro that they made the same reference to Jurassic Park that I had. The
article makes strong points for de-extinction. Since humans did wipe out these
animals by hunting them or destroying their habit we should help bring them
back. The article kept my attention through this park since it kept me thinking
and convincing me for this idea. The idea that a woolly mammoth could be
brought back to life defiantly peaked my interest. It seems impossible but with
advanced in technology we are seemingly right on the edge. I liked the reference
to 1813 when the pigeons would blanket the sky. It’s really mind blowing to
think that a species of such abundance was destroyed because of human hunting
and human activity. The article does close on the more realistic note that even
though we are close it is still years away. Also the question of would these
animals be able to survive will come up over and over again. I liked this
article. It made an idea that seems to come straight from science fiction as a possibility
over the coming years.
Friday, April 4, 2014
Chasing Lightning Blog
This article starts off with very strong imagery. We can
picture was it would have been like to inside the car and looking off into the
huge clouds and seeing the lightning. We even get to see the windshield covered
in crushed bugs and the cracks that the hail in forming. We also see that end
of the storm and the rainbow which forms. The opening scene that the author
describes is used as a cliff hanger. After the first scenario the author goes
back and explains what the article is about. What help keep my attention
through the whole article was the facts that the author wrote which were that
we still don’t know everything about lightning. A picture of lightning striking
the ground would be able to help these questions. I was also very interest in
the camera system which could take images less than one-millionth of a second
apart. It also helps keep attention is the fact that the chances of catching the
lightning in the wild is close to zero due to the long time it takes to operate
Kahuna and he has to be facing the lightning directly. The article does begin
the lose excitement as it gets closer to the end. The ability to catch the
picture in the wild is almost impossible. Even when the lightning strikes are
triggered by rocket the new and improved Kahuna couldn't capture the picture because
of the window in which the machine can take pictures. The article ends with Samaras still on the chase
for the picture of the lightning strike.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)